Written by Tom Lees, Founder and CEO of Bradshaw Advisory.
What happened yesterday?
Yesterday Alan Milburn published his long-awaited review of young people and work, a 278-page report with the rather Blair-era title From a Welfare State to a Working State.
The Work and Pensions Secretary, Pat McFadden, commissioned the former Labour health secretary last year, under Sir Keir Starmer, to examine why nearly one million 16- to 24-year-olds are not in education, employment or training (NEET). An interim report in May set out the problem. This final report is about what to do.
The numbers are stark. Around 13 per cent of young people are NEET. Across Europe, only Romania has a higher rate. Most are economically inactive rather than looking for work, and six in ten have never had a job.
Milburn's argument is that this is "not a crisis of aspiration; it is a crisis of opportunity". His answer is a 10-year programme and a "generational promise" that every young person will be guaranteed the opportunity to earn or learn.
The ambition is to get the NEET rate down to around 5 percent by 2036 or 'NEET Zero'. The modelling is more cautious: the policies as set out get the rate to around 6.8 percent, helping about 440,000 young people into sustained work.
At the centre of the new system is a locally led Youth Opportunity Service, including one named adviser and a personalised plan.
A statutory Opportunity and Support Guarantee would provide each eligible young person with a route into a college place, training, an apprenticeship, work experience or a job.
The backstop is a paid six-month job after 12 months rather than 18, a change the government has already accepted.
A further step is an overhaul of the benefits system for under-25s. Instead of Universal Credit a Youth Allowance would be paid at the same rate, or higher for those living independently. Universal Credit health top-up and Personal Independence Payments would be replaced by more targeted help with extra costs and a stronger safety net for those with the most severe conditions. Persistent refusal to engage could eventually mean losing the Youth Allowance, though the report says sanctions "should be rare and reviewed regularly".
Milburn is frank that the changes "will not be pain-free" and that some people could get less money at the start of a claim.
For firms, taking on a young person who has been NEET for six months would garner £3,000, with extra payments for small businesses, care leavers and disabled young people. The wider incentive package is put at around £1.1bn a year once scaled up, and is intended to create an additional 170,000 job and apprenticeship opportunities.
On National Insurance, he wants a five-year glide path to lower employer NI for 21- to 24-year-olds.
Apprenticeships are "the largest education and skills priority". Milburn wants to double the number of young people completing one over the next decade.
He recommends earlier intervention in schools, faster mental health support, and a 'youth opportunity test' so that tax and regulatory decisions are assessed for their impact on younger workers.
The cost is not small, and the savings are not quick. By 2036-37 annual investment would be around £5.8bn, offset by a supposed £3.6bn of welfare savings and £2.4bn in extra tax and lower benefit payments from higher employment. Though, as the Financial Times noted, these welfare savings rely on roughly halving the projected bill for sickness benefits for young people.
The government has accepted the core principles: the Opportunity and Support Guarantee, more local delivery, and the creation of a Youth Opportunities Unit at the centre of government. The Jobs Guarantee will be brought forward to 12 months. A white paper will follow in the new year, with legislation after that. The more contested recommendations, including National Insurance and employment-law changes, have not been accepted in full.
How did the media react?
The Times treated the report as the start of a wider welfare argument. Its main piece focused on Burnham's wish to extend the philosophy of the report to over-25s, with him describing today's jobcentre system as "soul-destroying”. The paper also flagged the early difference between Milburn's warning of short-term cash losses and the prime minister's insistence that no young person should be worse off.
The Financial Times said Burnham had accepted Milburn's central recommendations and promised legislation next year. It also reported that key Labour MPs who helped block Starmer's £5bn welfare cuts last year were backing the new plans. Josh Fenton-Glynn, a leading figure in that rebellion, told the Commons “This is a serious attempt to get people back into work."
Xiaowei Xu of the Institute for Fiscal Studies said the reforms could benefit people's life chances, but that the long-term savings were not so concrete. "If the reforms are less effective at moving people into work than expected, the package could end up costing the government more, even in the long run."
Bloomberg reported the same warning, and that the plan would be "competing for public service budgets" at next year's spending review.
The Guardian was broadly sympathetic to the ambition and nervous about the distributional detail. Patrick Butler described the report as "a blueprint for how to fix everything and everyone". However, the paper's editorial warned that young people "cannot be expected to take promised opportunities on trust".
What of the political fallout?
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said her party agreed with Milburn's "diagnosis" but argued that Labour had worsened circumstances by raising employer National Insurance and the youth minimum wage.
Nigel Farage said he agreed in sentiment but thought it lacked the necessary urgency. Reform's economy spokesman, Robert Jenrick, was blunter: "We may be bankrupt before Burnham takes the tough decisions needed”.
The alternative offer from the Conservatives and Reform, as reported in the Telegraph, is much larger welfare savings, and a much smaller role for new state programmes.
On Burnham’s left flank, Green Party leader Zack Polanski called the proposals a "flimsy sticking plaster" intended to "slash support for disabled young people while subsidising corporations to hire cheap labour".
On the left there are worries that the £3.6bn of welfare savings will mean those with real health issues and disabilities could get unfairly caught up in the cuts. From the right, the critique was almost the mirror image: too much state, too little incentive, and savings that arrive too late.
What about business?
Business reaction was warmer than the political fight, at least on the hiring-cost parts of the report, though some wanted a faster move than Milburn is offering.
Rain Newton-Smith, chief executive of the CBI, called it "a once in a generation chance" and welcomed the proposal to cut employer National Insurance for young workers, while warning that "getting the landing zone right on measures such as guaranteed hours" would matter.
The Institute of Directors was blunter. Alex Hall-Chen laid blame on the Employment Rights Act, minimum wage hikes, and National Insurance changes as suppressing hiring, specifically that of young people. IoD research found that only one in five employers said hiring incentives would make them more likely to recruit young people in the coming year.
The British Chambers of Commerce struck a similar note. Shevaun Haviland said almost a million young adults outside education, work or training was "a huge waste of talent that we simply cannot afford", and that firms had become "much more cautious on recruitment".
Justin King, the former chief executive of Sainsbury's and chair of National Lottery operator Allwyn, was more impatient. He told the Financial Times: "Given how dramatic, immediate and negative to youth employment prospects the Budget [in 2024] was, the pace of change in Milburn's proposals is disappointing."
Unions, unsurprisingly, want employee rights kept. Paul Nowak of the TUC called a legal right to training or a job "a gamechanger", but urged the Government to "crack on and deliver its guaranteed hours rights in full".
What's coming next?
The immediate test is not the report itself. It is what government chooses to accept, fund and legislate for.
A full response is due in the coming weeks, after Sir Stephen Timms's review of Personal Independence Payments. A white paper will follow in the new year, then legislation. Healey will have to decide how a 10-year programme sits with the fiscal rules and other claims on public service budgets.
There are at least three political tests.
The first is Labour's own backbenches. The early signs are better than they were for Starmer's cuts last year, helped by Burnham's insistence that support comes first and that no young person should lose out in cash terms. This may hold until, as Milburn's own report warns, some young disabled claimants start to receive less cash.
The second is whether the Government is prepared to act on the demand side, not just the supply side. Businesses will judge the review less by the new Youth Opportunity Service than by whether it becomes actually easier to hire and expand workforces.
The third is time. The Conservatives and Reform will keep arguing that savings of £200m after a decade is not serious welfare reform. There is also the temptation to dilute the plan before the benefits arrive.
The question for the next year is whether the opportunities are genuinely there before the entitlements change, and whether a 10-year programme can survive the shorter timetable of British politics.